• WELCOME TO THE TOWN OF WINSLOW, MAINE
»
• Visit and Explore Maine Blog
»
• The Best Lobster Roll in Portland, Maine: A Must-Try Delicacy for Seafood Enthusiasts!

Portland, Maine, a charming New England city, is a haven for seafood enthusiasts. Its picturesque waterfront is dotted with fishing boats that bring in fresh catches daily, and its restaurants are renowned for their culinary prowess, particularly when it comes to seafood. Among the many seafood delicacies that Portland has to offer, the lobster roll stands out as a must-try. This simple yet delectable dish, made with fresh, succulent lobster meat lightly dressed and served on a warm, buttered roll, is a true testament to Maine’s culinary heritage. But with so many places offering their own version of this classic dish, where can one find the best lobster roll in Portland? Let’s embark on a culinary journey to discover the top spots for this beloved delicacy.

The Criteria for the Best Lobster Roll

Before we dive into our list, let’s first establish what makes a great lobster roll. The best lobster rolls strike a perfect balance between simplicity and indulgence. They feature generous portions of fresh, sweet lobster meat, lightly dressed with mayonnaise or melted butter, and served on a warm, toasted roll. The lobster should be the star of the show, with the dressing and roll serving as complementary elements that enhance, rather than overpower, its natural flavor. The roll should be soft yet sturdy enough to hold the filling without falling apart. Lastly, the overall presentation should be appetizing, making you eager to take that first bite.

Eventide Oyster Co.

Eventide Oyster Co. is a modern seafood restaurant that has earned rave reviews for its unique take on the lobster roll. Instead of the traditional hot dog bun, Eventide serves its lobster roll on a steamed bun reminiscent of those used in Asian cuisine. The lobster meat is dressed in brown butter vinaigrette, which adds a rich, nutty flavor that perfectly complements the sweetness of the lobster. This innovative twist on the classic lobster roll has earned Eventide a loyal following and a reputation as one of the best places to enjoy this dish in Portland.

Bite Into Maine

Bite Into Maine offers a variety of lobster rolls that cater to different tastes. You can choose from six different styles: Maine (with mayonnaise), Connecticut (with hot butter), Picnic (with coleslaw, hot butter, and celery salt), Wasabi, Curry, or Chipotle. Each roll is generously filled with fresh, succulent lobster meat, ensuring a mouthful of lobster in every bite. With its diverse menu and commitment to quality, Bite Into Maine is a must-visit for any lobster roll enthusiast.

Highroller Lobster Co.

Highroller Lobster Co. takes a playful, creative approach to the lobster roll. You can customize your roll with a variety of sauces, from traditional options like mayo and warm butter to more adventurous choices like jalapeno mayo or charred pineapple mayo. The lobster meat is fresh and flavorful, and the rolls are toasted to perfection. If you’re looking for a lobster roll that’s a bit out of the ordinary, Highroller Lobster Co. is the place to go.

Portland Lobster Company

Portland Lobster Company offers a classic, no-frills lobster roll that lets the quality of the lobster shine through. The lobster meat is lightly dressed with mayo and served on a toasted, buttered roll. Each roll comes with a side of coleslaw and chips, making for a satisfying meal. With its waterfront location and live music, Portland Lobster Company offers not only delicious food but also a lively, enjoyable atmosphere.

Conclusion

Portland, Maine, is a city that takes its lobster rolls seriously. Whether you prefer a classic, straightforward lobster roll or one with a creative twist, you’re sure to find a lobster roll in Portland that will satisfy your cravings. So the next time you find yourself in this charming New England city, make sure to try one (or all) of these top-rated lobster rolls. You won’t be disappointed!