When it comes to pizza, Scarborough, Maine, is a hidden gem. This coastal town, known for its scenic beauty and historic charm, is also home to a thriving pizza scene. From traditional Italian pizzerias to innovative gourmet pizza joints, Scarborough offers a slice for every palate. Whether you’re a local or a tourist, a pizza connoisseur or a casual diner, this guide will help you navigate Scarborough’s pizza landscape and discover your own slice of heaven.

A Brief History of Pizza in Scarborough

Scarborough’s pizza history dates back to the mid-20th century when Italian immigrants brought their culinary traditions to Maine. Over the years, Scarborough has embraced pizza, making it a staple of the local food scene. Today, the town boasts a diverse range of pizzerias, each with its unique style and flavor.

What Makes Scarborough Pizza Special?

Scarborough pizza stands out for its quality ingredients, skilled craftsmanship, and innovative flavors. Many pizzerias source their ingredients locally, ensuring fresh and flavorful pizzas. The dough is often handmade, and the pizzas are baked in traditional wood-fired ovens. Moreover, Scarborough pizzerias are not afraid to experiment, offering unique toppings and creative combinations that set them apart.

Top Pizzerias in Scarborough

Scarborough is home to several outstanding pizzerias. Here are a few must-visit spots:

  • Pat’s Pizza: A Scarborough institution since 1985, Pat’s Pizza is known for its traditional hand-tossed pizzas. With a wide range of toppings and a cozy, family-friendly atmosphere, it’s a local favorite.
  • Portland Pie Company: This popular chain, which started in nearby Portland, offers gourmet pizzas with a unique Maine twist. Try their signature lobster pizza for a true taste of Scarborough.
  • Jimmy the Greek’s: If you’re looking for something different, head to Jimmy the Greek’s. This restaurant combines Greek and Italian flavors to create delicious and unique pizzas.
  • OTTO: Known for its creative toppings and artisanal approach, OTTO is a must-visit for pizza connoisseurs. Their mashed potato, bacon, and scallion pizza is a local legend.

Choosing the Right Pizza for You

With so many options, choosing the right pizza in Scarborough can be overwhelming. Here are a few tips:

  • Know your preferences: Do you prefer thin-crust or thick-crust pizza? Traditional toppings or something more adventurous? Knowing your preferences can help narrow down your options.
  • Ask for recommendations: Locals know their pizza. Don’t hesitate to ask for recommendations, whether from friends, hotel staff, or even people on the street.
  • Try something new: Don’t be afraid to step out of your comfort zone. You might discover a new favorite!

Enjoying Your Scarborough Pizza

Finally, remember that pizza is meant to be enjoyed. Whether you’re dining in, taking out, or ordering delivery, take the time to savor your Scarborough pizza. Pair it with a local craft beer or a glass of wine, add a side salad or some garlic knots, and finish with a sweet treat like cannoli or gelato. After all, a trip to Scarborough isn’t complete without a taste of its delectable pizza.

In conclusion, Scarborough, Maine, is a pizza lover’s paradise. With its rich history, quality ingredients, and diverse range of pizzerias, it offers a unique pizza experience that’s worth exploring. So next time you’re in town, follow this guide, grab a slice, and discover your own piece of Scarborough pizza heaven.

Explore Maine's stunning trails with our ultimate hiking guide. Discover breathtaking outdoor adventures across the state....

Explore the preservation of Maine's historic gem, The Jordan Pond House, through meticulous reconstruction efforts....

Explore the untouched beauty of Belgrade, Maine. Immerse in its scenic landscapes, tranquil lakes, and charming wildlife....

Explore Waldoboro, Maine's historic fishing town. Discover its hidden gems, rich history, and unique coastal charm....